Heavy metals in different food products
Heavy metal contamination varies significantly between food products.
The heavy metals most commonly associated with different food products
Heavy metal contamination varies significantly between food products because different crops, animals, and food matrices absorb, accumulate, and retain heavy metals in different ways. Factors such as growing conditions, environmental contamination, food processing, and biological characteristics all influence which heavy metals are most likely to be present.
As a result, certain food categories, such as rice, seafood, cocoa, and leafy vegetables, require more targeted monitoring than others. This page explains the heavy metals most commonly associated with different food products, why they occur, and the factors that influence their concentrations.
Rice & cereals
Rice is the food category most closely associated with arsenic contamination because it is cultivated under flooded, anaerobic paddy conditions. These conditions increase the bioavailability of inorganic arsenic in the soil, allowing rice plants to absorb substantially more arsenic than cereals such as wheat or maize, which are grown under aerobic conditions. Since inorganic arsenic is considerably more toxic than organic arsenic species such as arsenobetaine, its concentration in rice is subject to strict regulatory limits.
Rice and rice-based products can differ considerably in their arsenic content. Brown rice generally contains higher concentrations than white rice because arsenic accumulates primarily in the bran layer, which is removed during polishing. Rice cakes, rice crackers, and rice-based infant cereals may also contain relatively high concentrations of inorganic arsenic, as processing can concentrate the mineral content by reducing the water and carbohydrate content.
The amount of arsenic present in rice is influenced not only by cultivation practices but also by rice variety and growing location. Rice produced in parts of South and Southeast Asia, where groundwater naturally contains elevated arsenic concentrations, often shows higher inorganic arsenic levels than rice grown in regions without these geological conditions.
To protect consumers, EU Regulation 2023/915 establishes maximum levels for inorganic arsenic in rice products, including:
- 0.20 mg/kg for polished rice
- 0.25 mg/kg for husked rice
- A stricter limit of 0.10 mg/kg for rice intended for infants and young children
Fish & seafood
Mercury, particularly methylmercury, is the primary heavy metal concern in fish and seafood. Methylmercury is formed when microorganisms convert inorganic mercury into its organic form in aquatic sediments. It then bioaccumulates in individual organisms and biomagnifies through the aquatic food chain, causing concentrations to increase at each trophic level.
As a result, long-lived predatory fish such as tuna, swordfish, shark, and marlin generally contain significantly higher methylmercury concentrations than smaller, shorter-lived species.
Fish and seafood can also accumulate other heavy metals depending on their habitat and feeding behaviour. Filter-feeding shellfish, including bivalve molluscs, can accumulate cadmium from surrounding sediments and water at concentrations considerably higher than those present in the aquatic environment. Consequently, cadmium is an additional contaminant of concern for certain shellfish species.
To protect consumers, EU Regulation 2023/915 establishes different maximum levels for mercury in fish based on the expected degree of bioaccumulation. The maximum level is:
- 0.50 mg/kg for most fish species
- 1.0 mg/kg for specific predatory species, including swordfish, shark, and certain tuna species
The regulation also sets maximum levels for cadmium in bivalve molluscs and crustaceans. Due to the developmental neurotoxicity of methylmercury, several EU member states recommend that pregnant women and other vulnerable groups limit their consumption of fish species known to contain higher mercury concentrations.
Cocoa & chocolate
Cadmium is the primary heavy metal concern in cocoa and chocolate products. Unlike many other cases of heavy metal contamination, cadmium in cocoa is predominantly of geogenic origin, meaning it occurs naturally in the environment rather than resulting from industrial pollution. Cacao grown in parts of Ecuador, Peru, and the Dominican Republic often shows elevated cadmium concentrations because the volcanic soils in these regions naturally contain higher levels of the element. As a result, cacao trees can absorb cadmium from the soil even in the absence of anthropogenic contamination.
The cadmium concentration in cocoa products is also influenced by processing. During fermentation, drying, and the production of cocoa liquor, cocoa powder, and cocoa butter, water is removed and the composition of the raw material changes, increasing the cadmium concentration per unit weight. Consequently, cocoa powder generally contains higher cadmium concentrations than finished chocolate products.
To protect consumers while accounting for these natural and processing-related differences, EU Regulation 2023/915 establishes category-specific maximum levels for cadmium in chocolate and cocoa-derived products. The permitted concentrations range:
- 0.10 mg/kg for chocolate containing less than 30% cocoa solids
- 0.80 mg/kg for cocoa powder
- Intermediate limits for products containing higher cocoa contents
Fruits & vegetables
Lead and cadmium are the primary heavy metals of concern in fruits and vegetables. These elements can enter crops through several pathways, including uptake from contaminated soil, atmospheric deposition onto leaves and fruit surfaces, and the use of contaminated irrigation water. The extent of contamination depends on both environmental conditions and the characteristics of the crop.
Leafy vegetables such as spinach and lettuce generally accumulate higher concentrations of lead and cadmium than fruiting vegetables. This is due to their larger leaf surface area, which increases exposure to atmospheric deposition, as well as differences in root uptake and metal transport within the plant.
Vegetables grown near historical industrial sites, mining operations, or major roadways may require closer monitoring, as localised soil contamination can result in heavy metal concentrations significantly above regional background levels, even when the crop variety itself is not particularly prone to accumulation.
To account for differences in uptake and consumption patterns, EU Regulation 2023/915 establishes category-specific maximum levels for cadmium in vegetables, with separate limits for root vegetables and tubers, leafy vegetables, and fruiting vegetables.
Herbs & spices
Lead is the primary heavy metal concern in herbs and spices. While contamination can occur through the same pathways as other plant-based foods, including soil uptake and atmospheric deposition, spices are also associated with a distinct contamination route: deliberate adulteration. One of the best-documented examples is the addition of lead chromate to turmeric to enhance its yellow colour and increase its apparent value. Unlike environmental contamination, this practice is considered food fraud and has been identified in multiple international investigations.
Herbs and spices present a unique analytical challenge because they are typically consumed in small quantities but can contain relatively high heavy metal concentrations on a weight basis. As a result, both concentration and actual dietary exposure must be considered when assessing potential health risks.
To address these risks, EU Regulation 2023/915 establishes maximum levels for lead in herbs and spices, distinguishing them from many other food categories. In addition, lead-contaminated spice consignments, particularly turmeric and paprika, are regularly reported through the Rapid Alert System for Food and Feed (RASFF), highlighting the continued importance of monitoring and authenticity testing within the herb and spice supply chain.
Baby food
Baby food and infant formula are subject to the strictest heavy metal limits of any food category because infants have a lower body weight, developing organ systems, and a higher food intake relative to their body weight than adults. As a result, even low concentrations of heavy metals can contribute to proportionally higher exposure.
Inorganic arsenic in rice-based infant cereals, lead in fruit and vegetable purees, and cadmium in a range of infant food ingredients are among the most closely monitored contaminant-food combinations.
Regulatory scrutiny of this category increased following the 2021 US Congressional report on heavy metals in baby food. Although the investigation focused on the United States, it prompted many European manufacturers to adopt internal specifications well below the legal maximum levels established by the European Union as a precautionary measure. This has encouraged the use of dedicated low-heavy-metal sourcing programmes for infant food ingredients, together with more frequent batch testing than is typically performed for comparable adult food products.
Dairy
Dairy products generally contain lower heavy metal concentrations than many plant-based foods or seafood. Unlike mercury in aquatic food chains, heavy metals do not bioaccumulate to the same extent through the mammalian lactation pathway. As a result, milk and dairy products typically show relatively low background concentrations of heavy metals.
Lead and cadmium can nevertheless enter milk through contaminated livestock feed, grazing land, or drinking water. Consequently, monitoring the heavy metal content of animal feed and water supplies is an important upstream control measure within dairy food safety programmes.
EU Regulation 2023/915 establishes a comparatively low maximum level for lead in raw milk, reflecting both the typically low background contamination and the importance of dairy products in the diet of all age groups, including infants consuming dairy-based infant formula. Feed-to-milk transfer of heavy metals is considerably lower than the transfer observed for many other contaminant classes, which is one reason dairy products generally require less intensive heavy metal monitoring than higher-risk food categories such as rice, cocoa, or seafood.
Drinking water
Drinking water is both a direct source of heavy metal exposure and an indirect contributor through its use in food and beverage production. Arsenic and lead are the primary heavy metals of concern. Arsenic typically originates from naturally occurring geological sources in groundwater, while lead is most commonly associated with ageing distribution systems, lead-containing pipes, and plumbing components.
Because water is used throughout the food production chain, from food processing and beverage production to ingredient preparation, maintaining high water quality is essential for food safety. Contaminated water can contribute directly to heavy metal concentrations in finished food products and beverages.
EU Directive 2020/2184 establishes parametric values for heavy metals in drinking water, including a lead limit that will be reduced from 10 µg/L to 5 µg/L by 2036. This reflects the current scientific understanding that no safe threshold for lead exposure has been identified. Bottled water and water used as a direct food ingredient are regulated separately under Regulation (EU) 2023/915, which establishes maximum levels appropriate to their intended use and consumption.
Food supplements
Food supplements can show considerable variation in heavy metal content because contamination depends largely on the origin of the raw materials rather than the manufacturing process. Supplements derived from botanical, algal, or marine sources are particularly susceptible, as these materials can naturally accumulate heavy metals from their growing environment.
Algae-based supplements, including certain seaweed and kelp products, are recognized for elevated arsenic concentrations and, in some cases, high iodine content due to the natural bioaccumulation characteristics of marine algae.
Botanical supplements sourced from regions with naturally elevated soil heavy metal concentrations may likewise contain higher levels than their conventional food counterparts, particularly because supplements are often produced as concentrated extracts rather than whole foods.
To account for these differences, EU Regulation 2023/915 establishes specific maximum levels for food supplements that differ from those applied to the conventional foods from which their ingredients are derived. Because supplements are typically more concentrated and offer limited opportunities for dilution or blending during production, thorough raw material testing and review of supplier certificates of analysis (CoAs) are important control measures for supplement manufacturers.
Edible oils
Edible oils generally present a lower heavy metal contamination risk than many other food categories. During oil extraction and refining, heavy metals remain primarily associated with the water-soluble, protein, and fibre fractions of the raw material rather than partitioning into the lipid fraction. As a result, refined edible oils typically contain relatively low concentrations of heavy metals.
Nevertheless, heavy metal contamination can still occur. The concentration of heavy metals in the original oilseed, contamination introduced during pressing or extraction, and, in some documented cases, inappropriate storage or transport containers can all affect the quality of the finished oil.
Refining processes such as degumming, neutralisation, and bleaching can further reduce the heavy metal content of crude oils. Consequently, refined oils generally contain lower concentrations than their corresponding crude or cold-pressed equivalents. This is particularly relevant for the growing market for cold-pressed and unrefined oils, where the absence of refining steps means that any heavy metals present in the raw oilseed are more likely to remain in the finished product.
Learn more about heavy metals in food
Discuss your food analysis requirements
Our Xperts are happy to discuss your application and help you find the right solution.
FAQ
Why does rice contain more arsenic than other cereals?
Rice typically contains more arsenic than cereals such as wheat or maize because it is grown in flooded paddy fields. These anaerobic conditions increase the bioavailability of inorganic arsenic in the soil, allowing rice plants to absorb more arsenic during growth.
Does brown rice contain more arsenic than white rice?
Yes. Brown rice generally contains higher arsenic concentrations because arsenic accumulates in the outer bran layer, which remains intact in brown rice but is removed during the polishing process used to produce white rice.
Which fish contain the highest mercury concentrations?
Large predatory fish such as tuna, swordfish, shark, and marlin typically contain the highest mercury concentrations. These species accumulate methylmercury through a process known as biomagnification.
Is cadmium in chocolate caused by pollution?
Not necessarily. In many cocoa-producing regions, cadmium occurs naturally in the soil and is absorbed by cacao trees without any contribution from industrial pollution.
Which vegetables are most likely to require heavy metal monitoring?
Leafy vegetables, vegetables grown near industrial areas, and crops cultivated on contaminated soils generally require closer monitoring for lead and cadmium.
Can drinking water contain heavy metals?
Yes. Drinking water can contain heavy metals such as arsenic and lead. Arsenic often originates from natural geological sources, while lead is commonly associated with ageing pipes and plumbing systems.
Which heavy metals are most closely monitored in baby food?
Inorganic arsenic, lead, and cadmium are among the heavy metals most closely monitored in infant foods and baby food ingredients.
Do dairy products contain heavy metals?
Dairy products can contain trace amounts of heavy metals, but concentrations are typically lower than those found in many plant-based foods and seafood.