How can laboratories improve repeatability in food composition analysis?

Laboratories can improve repeatability in food composition analysis by standardising every step of the workflow, from sample preparation and instrument calibration to data monitoring and method validation. The key is eliminating variability at its source, because inconsistency anywhere in the process compounds into unreliable results. The sections below address the most critical questions QC and R&D labs face when working to achieve consistent, reproducible food analysis.

What are the most common sources of poor repeatability in food composition analysis?

Poor repeatability in food composition analysis most commonly stems from inconsistent sample preparation, instrument drift, operator variability, and inadequate use of reference materials. In food matrices, which are often complex and heterogeneous, even small deviations in how samples are handled or measured can produce results that cannot be reproduced between runs or operators.

Understanding where variability enters the process is the first step toward controlling it. The most frequent culprits include:

  • Heterogeneous sample matrices. Food samples vary naturally in composition, so sub-sampling errors are common if homogenisation is insufficient before analysis.
  • Operator technique. Differences in how analysts weigh, dilute, or transfer samples introduce human-driven variability that is often underestimated.
  • Instrument condition. Dirty optics, worn electrodes, or uncleaned digestion vessels all degrade measurement consistency over time.
  • Environmental factors. Temperature fluctuations, humidity, and airborne contamination affect moisture analysis repeatability and other sensitive determinations.
  • Calibration gaps. Infrequent or poorly matched calibration standards allow instrument response to drift between measurement sessions.

Addressing these sources systematically, rather than reactively, is what separates high-performing QC labs from those that struggle with out-of-specification results.

How does sample preparation affect analytical repeatability?

Sample preparation is one of the greatest contributors to poor repeatability in food analysis. If the sample reaching the instrument is not representative, homogeneous, and consistently prepared, no amount of instrument precision will compensate. Errors introduced during preparation are amplified throughout the rest of the analytical workflow.

For fat content analysis, protein analysis reproducibility, and elemental analysis in food, the preparation step often involves grinding, drying, digestion, or extraction. Each of these steps introduces potential variability if not tightly controlled. Particle size after milling, for example, directly affects extraction efficiency in fat determination. Incomplete digestion in elemental analysis leads to artificially low results that cannot be reproduced.

Automation of sample preparation steps, such as automated weighing, solvent addition, or digestion systems, significantly reduces operator-to-operator variability. Standardised protocols with defined tolerances for each step, combined with documented preparation records, form the foundation of a repeatable analytical method.

Which instrument parameters have the greatest impact on reproducibility?

The instrument parameters with the greatest impact on analytical reproducibility are temperature stability, detector sensitivity, carrier gas or solvent flow rates, and the condition of consumable components such as electrodes, membranes, or crucibles. These parameters determine whether the instrument responds consistently to the same analyte concentration across multiple runs.

In moisture analysis, for instance, the temperature profile of a drying oven or halogen analyser must be tightly controlled to achieve moisture analysis repeatability. Deviations of even a few degrees can shift results meaningfully for high-moisture food products. In elemental analysis for food applications, plasma temperature, nebuliser performance, and torch alignment all influence signal stability.

Routine instrument performance checks, sometimes called system suitability tests, should be run at the start of each analytical session. These checks verify that key parameters are within defined limits before any sample results are generated, ensuring that reproducibility is confirmed rather than assumed.

What role do reference materials and calibration standards play in food analysis?

Reference materials and calibration standards are essential tools for ensuring that food composition analysis produces accurate and repeatable results. Certified reference materials (CRMs) allow laboratories to verify that their method and instrument are performing correctly, while calibration standards define the instrument’s response curve against known concentrations.

In food quality control, using matrix-matched reference materials, those that closely resemble the actual food sample in composition, reduces the risk of matrix effects distorting results. A calibration standard prepared in pure solvent may not behave the same as one in a complex food digest, which can introduce systematic bias that undermines reproducibility across different sample types.

Calibration frequency also matters. For high-throughput QC labs, bracketing sample batches with calibration standards and CRMs at the beginning and end of a run is a widely adopted practice. It confirms that the instrument response has remained stable throughout the batch, and it provides documented evidence of method performance for compliance purposes.

How can laboratories use statistical tools to monitor and control repeatability?

Laboratories can use statistical process control (SPC) tools, particularly control charts, relative standard deviation (RSD) calculations, and trend analysis, to monitor and control repeatability in food analysis over time. These tools transform individual measurement results into a continuous picture of method performance, making it possible to detect drift before it causes out-of-specification results.

A practical approach to statistical monitoring involves the following steps:

  1. Establish baseline performance. Run a representative number of replicates under controlled conditions to determine the method’s inherent variability and set control limits.
  2. Plot control charts. Track QC sample results on Levey-Jennings or Shewhart charts, flagging any results that fall outside two or three standard deviations from the mean.
  3. Calculate RSD regularly. Relative standard deviation across replicate measurements is a quick indicator of whether repeatability is within acceptable bounds for the method.
  4. Investigate trends, not just failures. A series of results drifting in one direction, even within limits, often signals an emerging problem such as reagent degradation or instrument wear.
  5. Document and review. Maintain records of statistical outputs and review them periodically to identify systemic issues that single-point checks would miss.

Statistical monitoring turns repeatability from a reactive concern into a proactive quality management practice.

When should a laboratory consider upgrading instrumentation to improve food analysis results?

A laboratory should consider upgrading instrumentation when statistical monitoring consistently shows that repeatability is outside acceptable limits despite optimised sample preparation, correct calibration, and operator training. If the method and workflow are sound but results remain inconsistent, the instrument itself has likely become the limiting factor.

Other clear indicators include increasing maintenance frequency, difficulty sourcing replacement parts, and instruments that no longer meet current software or compliance requirements, such as 21 CFR Part 11 audit trail functionality for regulated environments. In food quality control labs operating under regulatory scrutiny, outdated instrumentation can create compliance risk as well as analytical risk.

Before committing to an upgrade, it is worth conducting a formal method capability assessment. This involves comparing the instrument’s current measurement uncertainty against the required tolerance for the analyte and matrix in question. If the instrument cannot reliably distinguish between acceptable and non-conforming product, the business case for replacement is straightforward.

How SciSPX supports better repeatability in food composition analysis

SciSPX works with QC, R&D, and analytical laboratories across the Benelux to address exactly the challenges described in this article, from inconsistent sample preparation to instrument qualification and statistical method validation. The team combines high-end laboratory instruments with genuine application expertise, so customers receive guidance that goes beyond the instrument itself.

SciSPX’s support for food composition analysis includes:

  • Expert advice on instrument selection matched to the specific matrix, analyte, and throughput requirements of the lab
  • IQ/OQ installation and validation services in line with GMP and GLP standards, ensuring instruments perform to specification from day one
  • Application-level support from Product Specialists who work alongside lab technicians to optimise methods and reduce variability
  • Preventive and corrective maintenance programmes that keep instrumentation performing consistently over time
  • Guidance on calibration strategies and the use of reference materials appropriate for food matrices

If your laboratory is experiencing repeatability challenges or is evaluating new instrumentation for food quality control, contact SciSPX to speak with a specialist who understands your application.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many replicates should we run to establish a reliable repeatability baseline for a new food analysis method?

As a general starting point, most method validation guidelines (including ISO 5725 and AOAC protocols) recommend a minimum of 6–10 replicate measurements under repeatable conditions to establish a meaningful baseline. For food matrices with high natural variability — such as emulsified products or composite foods — running at least 10 replicates across multiple days and operators gives a more robust picture of the method’s true precision. The goal is to generate enough data to set statistically defensible control limits, not just a rough average.

What is an acceptable RSD (relative standard deviation) for food composition analysis, and how do we know if our results are out of range?

Acceptable RSD values depend on the analyte, concentration level, and matrix complexity — there is no single universal threshold. As a practical benchmark, RSDs below 2% are generally considered excellent for major components like fat or protein at high concentration levels, while RSDs up to 5–10% may be acceptable for trace elements or low-concentration analytes in complex matrices. The best approach is to compare your RSD against the performance criteria defined in your validated method or the relevant regulatory/accreditation standard (e.g., ISO 17025), rather than applying a generic cutoff.

Our repeatability is good within a single run but degrades significantly between runs or between days — what is likely causing this?

This pattern is a classic sign of intermediate precision problems rather than within-run repeatability issues, and the most common culprits are instrument warm-up inconsistency, reagent or standard degradation between sessions, and environmental fluctuations such as temperature changes overnight. Start by checking whether your system suitability test results at the start of each run are stable, and whether your calibration standards are freshly prepared or stored correctly. Implementing a bracketed calibration strategy — running standards at the beginning and end of every batch — is one of the most effective ways to catch and correct between-run drift before it contaminates your sample results.

How do we decide which steps in our sample preparation workflow to automate first?

Prioritise automating the steps that introduce the most operator-to-operator variability and that are performed most frequently — typically weighing, liquid addition, and dilution. A useful exercise is to have two or three analysts independently prepare the same sample following your current SOP and compare the results; the steps where outcomes diverge most are your highest-priority automation targets. Automated gravimetric dispensers, robotic liquid handlers, and closed-system digestion platforms are well-established entry points for food labs looking to reduce human-driven variability without overhauling the entire workflow.

Can we use in-house reference materials instead of certified reference materials (CRMs), and what are the trade-offs?

Yes, in-house reference materials (IHRMs) are a practical and widely used complement to CRMs, particularly for routine QC monitoring where running certified materials for every batch would be cost-prohibitive. The key trade-off is traceability: CRMs carry certified values with documented uncertainty and metrological traceability, making them essential for method validation, accreditation audits, and resolving disputes. IHRMs work well for day-to-day control chart monitoring, but they should always be anchored to CRM measurements during their initial characterisation to ensure the assigned values are reliable.

What is the difference between repeatability and reproducibility, and why does it matter for our food lab's QC programme?

Repeatability refers to the agreement between results obtained under the same conditions — same operator, same instrument, same day — while reproducibility describes agreement across different conditions, such as different operators, instruments, or laboratories. For an internal QC programme, both matter: good repeatability tells you your method is consistent within a session, but poor reproducibility reveals that your SOP is not robust enough to transfer reliably between analysts or shifts. If your lab produces results that will be compared against supplier data, regulatory limits, or inter-laboratory proficiency schemes, understanding and controlling reproducibility is just as important as tightening within-run repeatability.

How often should we re-validate our food analysis methods, and what triggers an out-of-cycle revalidation?

Routine periodic review is typically conducted annually as part of a quality management system, but several events should trigger an immediate out-of-cycle revalidation: instrument replacement or major repair, a change in reagent supplier or grade, a significant modification to the SOP, or a pattern of control chart failures that cannot be explained by a transient cause. For regulated environments operating under GMP or ISO 17025, any change that could affect method performance must be assessed and documented before the modified method is used for reportable results. A pragmatic approach is to maintain a change control log and evaluate each change against predefined impact criteria to determine whether full revalidation, partial verification, or no action is required.

Related Articles

This content was generated with the help of AI and it may contain mistakes

Contact our Xperts

Prefer to give us a call?

The Netherlands
+31 (0)294 280 450

Belgium & Luxembourg
+32 (02)2 334 22 70